All reviews shown are from real guest experiences. Only travellers who have booked a stay with us can submit a review. We verify reviews according to our guidelines and publish all reviews, positive or negative.More informationOpens in a new window
Rating 10 - Excellent. 1973 out of 4187 reviews" "
This is a very rundown hotel. We come to NYC all the time and decided to stay here just to try it. It was bad! The property in general is dirty, the walls and carpet on the hallways are scratched and dusty. The bathrooms have tile work and sinks from the 90’s. Luckily our room was old and outdated but clean. They have security checking you every time you get on the elevator, which is very inconvenient. You have to pay for them to hold your bags at the reception and there isn’t much around that area.
Ricdamis
Stayed 1 night in Mar 2024
8/10 Good
Matt
27 Mar 2024
Liked: Staff & service
Comfortable bed and friendly staff. If on a budget this place is perfect and what you get for the price point is better than other hotels in NYC
Matt
Stayed 3 nights in Mar 2024
10/10 Excellent
Eileen
Travelled with family
27 Mar 2024
Liked: Cleanliness, staff & service
Close to our destination. Room was comfortable and at night the city view was nice. Bathroom could use some updating. Suitable for an overnight.
We really enjoyed our stay at the New Yorker Wyndham. Mohammad, who checked us in, was very friendly and even allowed us early check in and upgraded us to a fantastic room with a wonderful view. We will definitely stay here again.
Great location - room was tiny and extra fees for coffee maker seems silly. No shower liner, only curtain so water goes everywhere despite best efforts and tub clogged.
Overall fine for a night but would not select again.
The staff was great as was the room and location. Having Tic Toc diner right there was also a plus. The ONLY thing I had an issue with was a septic odor when you first entered the room. Seemed to dissipate once you were in for 5-10 minutes
The location was great, near the subway but also not a really far walk to many stores & restaurants.
very convenient. staff was wonderful...very helpful.
Great place for families, with many walkable attractions!
Gurnoor Amani
8/10 Good
Juliette
22 Mar 2024
Liked: Staff & service
Disliked: Amenities
Can't beat the location - near the subway, Penn Station and Times Square. It needs to be updated as some of the wall paper was peeling in my room. Staff (all but one) were really helpful and kind. Felt safe as there is security at the bottom of the elevators. Could have done without the shower turning hot and cold randomly. It can get scorching at times. I faced 34th so very quiet room but absolutely no view. You get what you pay for as my cousin had a view of the Empire State Building and her room was updated.
Dated. Very old. Tiny rooms. Requested room
With a view-- after moving to
The 3rd room we got it. Then it was so old and it smelled. We checked out got a refund and
Went
To the Lucerne. Horrible experience.
Excellent location for Amtrak and subway. Reasonable price for Manhattan. Bed very comfortable and clean. Very friendly cleaning staff on 22nd floor. Nice views. Lacks coffee/tea maker in room; that was the only shortcoming. Love the art deco decor. A little shabby, but perfectly acceptable.
I have been staying at this hotel for about 8 years and they never disappoint
Angela
Stayed 4 nights in Mar 2024
8/10 Good
Laura
Travelled with partner
17 Mar 2024
Location is close to everything!
Laura
Stayed 2 nights in Mar 2024
10/10 Excellent
Shannon
Business traveller
17 Mar 2024
Liked: Cleanliness, staff & service, amenities
Great customer service. Hotel is neat and classic, but a little worn. So close to everything, easy to walk, great dining options, including 24-hour diner downstairs.
Perfect location for me. Just across the road from Penn Station and easy to walk to battery Park, Chelsea and near venues I had booked. Housecleaning staff were good, drying my shoes for me after they were soaked in a downpour! Tick Tock diner is a great facility to have connected to the hotel and open 24 hours a day. Some of the decor in the room was a little past its best but all was clean and everything worked as it should. Will definitely be returning