4 Star Hotels in Pigeon Island, Gros Islet

"I recently stayed at Secrets St. Lucia and unfortunately would not recommend this resort. The experience started off on the wrong foot with a very confusing check-in process that took nearly an hour. Throughout the stay, most of the staff came across as rude and disengaged, with a few notable exceptions—Sanchey, in particular, was wonderful and stood out for their kindness and professionalism. The rooms themselves were disappointing. They felt dirty and not well-maintained, although I will say the bed was comfortable and the shower had great water pressure and plenty of hot water. The food was another major letdown—bland, overly salted, and generally uninspired across the board. It felt like very little thought or care went into the dining experience. Lastly, the events and entertainment felt poorly executed—more childish than engaging, and overall thrown together without much attention to quality. For the price, I expected a much higher level of service and overall experience. I left feeling very unsatisfied—especially after a manager argued with me when I tried to provide feedback, which only added to the disappointment. Overall, this was not the level of experience I expected, and I wouldn’t choose to stay here again."

"Stolen Times was a nice resort. There were many beautiful and wonderful aspects of it. Our room was nice and opened right to the beach, which was lovely. The beach is private and has umbrellas to sit under and the staff comes by with water or drinks. Staff is super super friendly and very accommodating (for the most part). If you are an adventurous eater, you would enjoy the food, I am not, so I did not. It was an all inclusive, but you could only get food at certain hours, and they DID NOT accommodate for any Western paletes. The worst part about the resort was the crickets. We were on a ground floor and they have large crickets that bite, but also make the LOUDEST noise- All. Night. Long!!!! It was awful. It really was too bad because we could've heard the nice ocean sounds all night, but we just heard this loud crying of the crickets. That was miserable. My tip is that if you are a non drinker, don't get the inclusive package because you are paying everyone else's alcohol. It was nice place , but I would not go there again. There is no way not to love the Caribbean. And the beach did not disappoint."

"Everything was amazing!"

"The room was nice, staff was mixed"