Independent hotels in Andros Island, Bahamas

"Just a perfect location for our kind of travel adventure! Warm and receptive hosts, great accommodations, & great location for do it yourself bonefishing. The kayaks on site were excellent, along with guides if you wanted to do that right in the neighborhood as well. Ocean frontage, (not really sunbathing beachfront), but using the kayaks or vehicle that the rental offers can get you to some for sure.This is an excellent spot for a quiet, slow paced island bonefishing adventures!We will be returning for sure!!! "

"All was great!!"

"Hidden gem in the Caribbean! Whether you’re a diver, a snorkeler, or just a swimmer, you’ll get to enjoy Mother Nature at its best. The staff is incredibly friendly. There’s a strong sense of community that we’ve never found at any other resort, which makes this place so special. Highly recommended!"

"We spent the first week of the New Year on Mangrove Cay at Scott’s house and had an incredible experience. The home is clean, comfortable, and thoughtfully equipped for island living. We were two couples, and although there’s one shared bathroom, the layout allows for plenty of privacy. The kitchen has everything needed for cooking, which mattered to us since we prefer making meals at home. The AC is ice cold, the beds are comfortable, and the sunrise views from the property are stunning. The private beach access made every morning feel special.The house also comes with excellent outdoor gear — paddle boards, a two-person kayak, snorkeling equipment, games, and more — which we used daily.What truly sets this stay apart is Scott. He is the best host we’ve ever had. Before arrival, he scheduled a Zoom call to walk us through the home and the island. During our stay, he checked in regularly and responded instantly to any questions. He even arranged a surprise birthday dinner for one of our group at Swain’s Cay Resort. That level of care is rare.Scott’s property manager Randy is also fantastic — a local fishing guide who took us snorkeling and lobster spearing. He embodies the warmth of the Mangrove Cay community. This island is not touristy — it’s quiet, authentic, and off the beaten path. We saw no other tourists, only friendly locals who made us feel at home.This was a top-tier stay in our travels, and we absolutely plan to return. If you’re looking for a true, private"

"The host Alicia was amazing. So, so helpful. The property itself is absolutely amazing. Spotlessly clean, perfect and new appliance and so close to the water you could crawl there. The area is fantastic too. There's a nearby restaurant, a convenience store and theres bike and kayak rental directly across the road. I cannot recommend this place hughly enough!"

"Had a fantastic experience. Lovely hosts who are very accommodating. Highly recommend."

"Great experience & location, close to Airport and car rental, friendly & helpful people, who were very welcoming and went way above & beyond the call of duty, I highly recommend it for anyone visiting South Andros. I look forward to my next visit. I will be back! (That's with my Arnold Swaznegger terminator voice & impression)"

"Rustic place but works for what you need it for."

"The house and stay was awesome. Great communication by the host and Junior. Hoping to stay there again soon. "