Chincoteague Hotel Guide - Captain Timothy Hill House hotels in Chincoteague, United States of America.

"Our 2nd visit. Love the hotel and the staff. It’s very peaceful and welcoming. Breakfast was great, room was wonderful. Hope to be back again someday! "

"Two night stay, very comfortable and clean"

"I stayed for a solo getaway on the weekend of 10/03 to 10/05/25. My stay was absolutely amazing from beginning to ending. "

"This was an exceptional rental property. It exceeded our expectations...and I think that says a lot about a place. The management company for this property were solid professionals. This property was immaculate. It was super clean. The decor was thoughtful, rich, and comforting. We wanted an amdience and vibe. This place nailed it! Highly recommended!"

"Great staff! Clean and"

"Stayed here with our little kids and we thought it was nice and would return. Nice and quiet property with a great view of the bay, but not completely isolated as there are other houses right next door with people and dogs out. Well appointed and clean kitchen. Basic bedrooms, the bed mattresses were good. The one (1) sleeper sofa mattress was as expected for a sleeper. Bathrooms had standard fixtures with some wear but were clean and worked. Common rooms had some wear but were clean. Nice couches. Use of the screened in porch was limited due to the number of holes in the screens and door gaps, but given how nice the great room was, it wasn't a huge issue for us. Washer/dryer worked well."

"Great week at Oyster Shack!"

"it was great lots of birds and wildlife. very comfortable and enjoyable older renovated home, part of history. really enjoyed the screened porch, lots of time spent there. very close to downtown and assateague park (wish they allowed our dachsunds). the only complaint is the ant problem, they were very busy in the kitchen. need to get it sprayed, the dried out ant traps not working. but all in all we will return (with terro ant traps). we rally enjoyed our stay!"

"Perfect, well equipped kitchen. Super clean with great bathrooms and comfy beds. Dog friendly and upstairs patio was nice hang out. Little touches like air hockey table and games/puzzles mean alot too! Loved the home."