LGBT-Friendly Hotels in Long Island

"One word: Perfection. OK, more words: Hosts were wonderful, villa was very clean and very well stocked, interior was beautiful, and the views were amazing! "

"Great resort. Staff was amazing. Lex, our ferryman was great. Stayed on Stocking island and loved every minute."

"Quaint property. Nice, clean villa. Dining options limited but they do provide free shuttle to town."

"100000000/10 stars. A true tropical paradise and we felt very taken of …. we did not want to leave. Will try to go back every year. Every picture is like a postcard but still doesn’t do the property justice. Lots of great new friends and adventures. "

"This place is an absolute hidden gem, truly one-of-a-kind and far beyond what we expected. I'm genuinely surprised it doesn’t have more reviews, because it deserves to be recognized for how exceptional it is. From the moment we arrived, we were completely captivated by the scenery—it’s like stepping into a postcard or a beautifully filmed nature documentary. The location is simply breathtaking, with crystal-clear waters that are hands down the most beautiful we’ve ever seen. We traveled with two toddlers, and the staff went above and beyond to make us feel welcome. They were kind, patient, and incredibly accommodating, which made our stay all the more enjoyable and relaxing. The warmth and hospitality we experienced here were second to none. Words truly fall short in capturing the peace and beauty of this place. It’s the kind of destination you want to keep to yourself, yet feel compelled to share because it’s just that special. We feel so fortunate to have discovered it. This is without a doubt one of the best-kept secrets we’ve ever come across."

"What an amazing stay and house! The home had everything we could have imagined and more. As my wife said "this house is the most stocked house we've stayed at." Great kitchen to cook in with a large variety of spices for cooking. This is oddly a huge thing for me as many rentals overlook this. The location is totally private and perfect with plenty to do right there. Off the beaten path but close enough to the markets for ease of food shopping. There is a great snorkeling spot (Blue Hole) just around the corner via kayak/SUP where we swam with sea turtles! They pop up every minute or so and are not hard to find. The low tide provides for opportunity to walk on a huge sand bar and see other marine species. The house has everything and then some and made our trip to Exuma so easy. The owner is extremely helpful from booking to checking out. We would 100% come back to this home for another stay in Exuma!"

"This villa felt so homely and had such a lovely soul, we have never felt so comfortable in a rented villa before. The kids loved playing in the calm waters around the villa and there is a really sweet little reef close by with quite a large array of small fish for the kids to snorkel around and look at. The beach is exposed at low tide and makes a lovely seating spot, as does the decking and pier! Sunrises are spectacular from here. The 2 rooms downstairs are on the outside of the property so more suited to older children but the area is very safe so we had no worries about our kids having their own “pad”. We took the free kayaks down to the nearby blue hole and saw sting rays, turtles and masses of fish - definitely worth while on a calm day. We cooked every night in the villa - it’s very well stocked with all the essentials and a few extras. 100% recommended "

"The property was well kept and in a good location. We enjoyed the pool and the beach area right out the back door. Definitely recommend this property."

"Our group of 10 had a great stay! Exuma is beautiful. The pool and beach were fantastic. All of us cooked & ate most breakfasts and dinners at the large indoor dining room table most days and it worked out great. The kitchen was fully stocked and worked well for this.Master bedroom and bath is very nice and spacious. 2nd bedroom with queen bed is big enough and has it's own bathroom. Loft bedroom is a little more private that we were thinking it would be, but it does not have a door so sound carries. Bunk room is back in the corner of the house so pretty private and quiet. Bunk room beds can work for adults, but much more ideal for kids/teenagers.We used the kayaks and paddle boards at the house as well as the pool many of the days. No-see-ums (sand flies) and regular flies are definitely a thing though during sunrise and sunset. I'm sure this is an issue across the entire island though so just plan to stay inside during those times. If you like to cook, make sure to get some fresh fish the guy set up right outside of Shop Rite. Definitely need a car(s) to get around the island. The host, Jacquelyn, gave us tips and suggestions that helped us plan a lot of it in advance so I'd suggest reaching out for that. Highly recommend a boat tour to the other Exuma islands with Go Adventures H2O as well as an ATV tour with Exuma Adventure Tours. Great vacation!"