Photo by National Parks Service
Wyndham Hotels hotels in Put-in-Bay, Ohio
Change your mindBook hotels with free cancellation
Be pickySearch almost a million properties worldwide
Check prices for these dates
Top Put-in-Bay Hotel Reviews
Islander Inn
8/10 Good
"The rooms need renovation and coffee. On the weekends it’s far too loud and the pool was dirty. The doors slam and you hear every one opening and closing their doors! Staff was helpful"
Cedar Point's Hotel Breakers
10/10 Excellent
"Staff was excellent. Great experience."
Anchor Inn Boutique Hotel
10/10 Excellent
"My husband and I stayed in the Wee Anchor Cottage for our 20th anniversary, and it was absolutely perfect. The cottage gave us the privacy of having our own little getaway while still enjoying all the amenities of the Anchor Inn. The property is beautifully maintained with gorgeous landscaping, charming porch seating areas, and a relaxing atmosphere that immediately makes you feel at home. One of our favorite parts of our stay was the breakfast. Not only was there a complimentary breakfast buffet each morning, but the chef also prepared incredible made-to-order breakfast specials that were included with our stay. Everything we tried was delicious, and it was such a wonderful way to start each day. The location was ideal. We were within easy walking distance of downtown Put-in-Bay, restaurants, shops, and attractions, but far enough away that we could escape the crowds and noise when we wanted to relax. The hotel’s quiet hours from 11 PM to 7 AM were greatly appreciated and made for peaceful nights of sleep. If you’re looking for a clean, comfortable, non-party atmosphere on Put-in-Bay, this is the place. The staff was welcoming, the property was beautiful, and the experience exceeded our expectations. We would absolutely stay here again and highly recommend the Wee Anchor Cottage and Anchor Inn to anyone looking for a relaxing island getaway."
Cedar Point's Express Hotel
10/10 Excellent
"Cool place"
Cedar Point's Castaway Bay
8/10 Good
"Cures resort. The added benefit of getting early access to cedar point was huge. I wish it would have had a pool open past 8pm though. The water park closed at 8 and having a nice lounging pool would have been nice after spending the day at the park. The room was fine. Comfy and convenient..our table was broken and saw some wear in places. Would have liked to have had a coffee maker in the room. Food was kinda pricy in the resort but overall a nice place."
Bayshore Resort at Put-in-Bay
10/10 Excellent
"Beautiful spot on the island!"
Commodore Resort
10/10 Excellent
"Clean rooms. Fun pool. Staff was very nice. Multiple bars were fun"
Bay Lodging Resort
10/10 Excellent
"The manager Dawn was amazing and very helpful with accommodating us. This was our first time at Putin Bay, and we will be back and staying at this lodge. The whole staff was very kind. The bartender was amazing. I love the whole set up. When we got there, our Golf cart was there and we got to use that. And Dawn put our stuff in the conference room until her room was ready. So we got to enjoy the day. What a blessing our stay was. Thank you."
Harbour Square Suites
10/10 Excellent
"Great location! Super friendly staff. Great accommodations!"