Search Cottages in Shelter Island

"Imagine a Super 8 motel or even something lower‑level that just put in new furniture and a new bathroom, but everything else stayed the same. It’s really not worth this price, to be honest. The rooms are clean but actually very small, and the hotel isn’t on the beach, there’s a dune and a road in between. Very bad insulation, you can hear people and their TVs from the rooms next to you."

"Had a hard time getting room cool enough to sleep ??"

"Lovey hotel, great staff, perfect for families."

"Wonderful experience from beginning to the end. Our check in was friendly, fast and easy efficient . Ethan and John were amazing. Room "

"Beautiful property near a picturesque town. I would definitely recommend. I’d love to return soon! "

"This place is absolutely horrible. In various states of disrepair, cracked floor, hard beds, all expenses spared, loud on all floors and staff does NOT answer the phones at any time. I am requesting a FULL refund. Horrible!!!"

"The hotel staff were extremely friendly and helpful, the rooms were immaculate and huge with plenty of room for us and the dog! Thoroughly enjoyed our stay! "

"Room was excellent and the beds were very comfortable. We went just prior to the season start so things were very calm. If i was to take issue with one thing; it would have been the shower was cool and never got hot. Not cold...but could have been warmer. "

"The kitchen was fully equipped and spotless. There were plenty of TV channels, and I loved the extra lighting in the room. The pool area and gym were also very clean. The attentive staff was the best part of the stay. "