Holiday Homes in Shelter Island

"I was first placed in a dirty room but they were very quick and efficient to move me which was great b/c I don’t like first floor rooms. In my second room on 2nd floor the window lock was broken so I couldn’t lock it. Uncomfortable but being in 2nd floor helped. Clock in the room nor working or unplugged?? Just used my fon for the clock. Breakfast area very clean and orderly and good. Parking lot had potholes but they were there fixing them today. Staff VERY friendly!!! "

"Lovely stay at Sag Harbor Inn. The room was great with a fantastic view of the water. The staff were super friendly and helpful."

"Great location. Rooms could use napkins or paper towels"

"Planning to stay here again! We had a great experience. Staff was great, rooms were clean. Location is close to a lot of restaurants and activities. Close to the wineries. Thank you to the staff who made this a great experience."

"I checked in during a severe snowstorm and had to leave the hotel within 30 minutes due to the conditions. Despite barely using the room, I was charged $304.50 as a “service fee.” I later reached out to the hotel to request clarification and a possible adjustment, but I have not received any response to this day. I understand that policies may apply, but charging such a significant amount for a stay of less than an hour—especially under unavoidable weather conditions—feels unreasonable and disappointing. The lack of communication from the hotel only adds to the frustration. I would appreciate a proper explanation and a fair resolution."

"Fridge and microwave, coffe"

"The Sagaponack Hotel is beautiful. The bed was comfortable, and the staff was wonderful. "

"Was clean unique didnt expect to see the rooms so nice for the price and the rooms are unique in its own way"

"View is stunning but rooms feel dated. Bathroom is extremely tiny and terrace had uncomfortable furniture."