Search Cottages in Sister Bay

"Loved the property. Great location to everything door county."

"We enjoyed the comforts of the cottage, s'mores at the fire pit, exploring North Bay, and equal distance drives to Bailey's, Ephraim, and Sister Bay. Smooth checkin and checkout. Needed minimal communication with host because their info sheet was great. 👍"

"My husband and I stayed here for a long weekend for our babymoon. The cottage is aesthetically beautiful and the fireplace and outdoor fire table were great touches to have. The location is perfect to see all of Door County. Would highly recommend!!"

"Decided on a last minute trip to an area we love. Had a great time. The property has a great view right on the water. Thank You"

"This was a great home. The common areas were spacious and the kitchen appeared well stocked. Some of the decor/finished were a little dated but the space itself was great. The outside area is amazing, there is a fire pit and a swing right on the water. Definitely would stay again."

"Overall highly satisfied with stay. House was so cute and everything you possibly could need was supplied. Highly recommend"

"We rented the Eagles Nest as a couples get away but it can actually sleep five (inc kids). Perfect location, blocks from the water but in a private wooded lot on three sides. No visual neighbors. Upper back balcony perfect breakfast spot for two. Clean, everything worked well, good wifi, good shower pressure and this place cost less for the whole cottage than a hotel or condo. Privacy for couples (or small families!) — We’d definitely rent it again."

"The pros:Check in was extremely easy and it was communicated perfectly on how to access building. We had a large group and the house was able to fit all of us and they were super cool about the additional members. I very much appreciated that. The house appeared to have everything we needed. We could not locate washer and dryer because usually during my stays I leave the house fully clean and I do the linens and towels and I wasn’t able to do that but the description stated there was a washer...

"This was our second stay and we stayed for 5 nights. We love it as it is dog friendly, clean and quaint. We enjoyed the fire pit, grill station, hammock and kayaking during sunsets. The views are incredible outside and from the inside. We stayed off season so it was quite chilly, but you can always warm up in the indoor sauna:). Great hiking opportunities in the nearby state parks (Newport and Death Door Bluff), The hosts are very friendly and responsive. Highly recommended!"

"The house was clean and comfortable. It was in a great location to walk Fish Creek."

"Lovely gardens surround this adorable cottage. Right on the edge of a dense forrest. Very well kept - a delightful stay"

"The Cat's Lair was great! We all loved the little cabin. Nicely decorated, fully equipped kitchen etc! The location was ideal with the woods all around, so relaxing. We also got the most beautiful colors to enjoy! Thank you so much Rory!"

"We all loved it! It was so cute and comfy! We enjoyed the fire pit one night. The location was great. Close to town, but secluded enough to be quiet. The cottage has everything you’ll need. Even a gas grill. Our ‘just girls’ stay was so much fun."

"Went to Sister Bay for Fall Festival. We LOVED this little house. It was perfect for our group. The kitchen had all the utensils we needed. The fireplace added a nice torch for chilly fall nights & the fire pit & grill were perfect for s’mores and steaks. The home was very clean and the beds were comfy. We would definitely stay again. Thank you!"

"A very pleasant place to relax and get rejuvenated. We were there for our 35th anniversary. Bonnie and Bob, had balloons, a card, and a bottle of wine awaiting us. A nice touch. The view and sound of the crashing waves was great, especially the beautiful sunrises. It was quiet except for the traffic on hwy 35 but we got used to it. We stayed for 1 week and we would definitely stay again."

"Very cozy and comfortable. View is gorgeous and the area is quiet. The condo. is well- appointed and has a very attractive bathroom with Jacuzzi tub. The deck is large and private. We enjoyed our visit very much and plan to return. On a side note: the hot water is scalding hot, so perhaps could be turned down to avoid accidental burn."

"Cute little place next to a park and within walking distance to everything."

"Very nice property- clean! Cute interior- had everything that was needed. Would stay here again! Reasonably priced also!"

"A very pleasant stay. The cottage is laid out very well. Everything you need. Owners were very quick to respond to questions. Location worked out very well to get around from Fish Creek to Gills Rock."

"Great location, down home feel, and nicely equipped with what we needed."