Search Treasure Cay Condo Rentals

"This house was beautiful and extremely spacious for our large group (3 couples with 7 kids 12-17). The downstairs was a perfect place for all the kids. They had their own kitchenette, bathroom, couch, table with chairs, and access to the pool and front of the house. We spent a ton of time on the expansive front porch, around the large kitchen island, and on the plush living room couches, watching movies at night. The pool was nice in the early parts of the day or later afternoon/evening as the midday sun made it a little toasty. Misty, the owner, was extremely attentive and responsive to any concerns or needs. We had a small issue on our arrival date with the prior guests leaving late, pushing our entry time back in order for her home to be cleaned. Misty responded with kindness and generous compensation. There is a dock at her other home (approx. 10min by golf cart) that is available if you have a boat. Sunset Pizza and Treasure Sands Beach Club are a must! The beach club serves lunch and dinner with a full-service bar, a pool for the kiddos, and access to the beach. I highly recommend renting a boat if you don't have one, to island hop. Big O's pigs on Nunjack Cay are awesome, Green Turtle, Guana, and Hopetown were amazing!!! We will be back. Thank you Misty."

"Better than expected. The house was clean and outfitted with everything needed to make your stay comfortable. Johnny and Allison are very quick to respond to questions. Felt completely comfortable with our boat at the dock. Best place we have stayed in Treasure Cay so far! "

"Very clean and maintained. Enjoyed the little extras like spices and seasonings. Extra sunscreen along with other items. Only stayed for 3nights very pleased. "

"We loved this house. The property was beautiful. The house was updated and in extremely good condition. The view was spectacular."

"Heaven on earth! From inquiry to check out this was the easiest rental we have stayed in in over 20 years of vacationing as a family. The villa is exactly as you see in the photos and description. The kitchen is stocked with everything you need and more. The bathrooms were equipped with plenty of towels. The Wi-Fi worked great. This is the most spacious and updated villa. The only downfall was that we didn’t stay longer! We are already planning our next visit! Thank you Ryan! "

"Excellent property. Excellent Owner and Manager! We had two families stay here in August 2025 and had a great time. Monika has done a great job at setting up her property to allow guests to enjoy the beauty and tranquility of treasure cay. "

"Just got back from an amazing stay at See You Next Time! We had a group of 10 (6 adults 4 kids) and we had more than enough space. The house is as beautiful as advertised! The pool was great and lots of marine life right at the dock! Also was nice to kayak/paddle board across the canal to the beach! Easy access in and out with our boat to get to where ever we wanted to go! Chloe was super helpful and responsive with any questions we had. Highly recommend!"

"All the essentials, easy check-in and checkout, literally steps from the beach. AC worked wonderful the whole time we were there, and hot water ample. Groceries and especially ice are easily twice as much as they are in the US just beware. Would recommend bringing your own flavored water and energy drinks in your checked luggage. Everything was very clean. There were a few ants, but I think is somewhat to be expected. We used the ant spray that was there and had no problem after that. Chairs and umbrellas were available to take on the beach. The complex has a The complex has a very clean pool that is a short walk. Ivan was an absolutely wonderful host and available anytime we had questions. Basic kitchen items such as coffee, salt and pepper were available. Bathroom items, such as shampoo and conditioner also were provided. The unit has a hairdryer as well. I would suggest bringing an ice tray so you can make your own ice. A small bag of ice was 20 at the convenient Mart across from the unit. This is a very quiet community and if that’s what you were looking for this is your place. It’s a bit away from the nightlife in Marsh Harbor so best to have a rental car as the drive is about 40 minutes one way. The pizza shop that is a five minute drive from the unit is to die for! Best pizza we’ve had in a very long time. It’s a brick oven. One suggestion is to purchase a couple bottles of liquor in the duty-free shops before leaving your home airport. We definitely will be back!"

"Well appointed two bedroom apartment on the ground floor just steps away from the ocean. We enjoyed our stay tremendously and hope to go back soon to enjoy the Bahama Beach Club once again. Thank you for hosting my cousin and I in Treasure Cay. "