Bayville Holidays

The hotel’s website showed beautiful, remodeled, spacious rooms with views, so I booked a nine-night stay. Unfortunately, what I found was nothing like the photos. I checked in late and immediately discovered the air conditioning was so loud that sleeping was unimaginable. The sconce between the beds was basically decorative, and the only other lights—four ceiling spots—were programmed to turn off every few minutes. I requested a room change and was given a much larger room on the first floor that felt more like a basement or warehouse. Totally wrinkled “Roman shades”, no rug, no bed blankets, the same useless lighting, and tinted windows facing a filthy terrace, leaving the room with virtually no natural light. The next morning, the shower ran cold for ages, then suddenly turned scorching hot with no way to regulate the temperature. So, for the third time, I returned to the front desk and requested another room—this time asking for the apparently unreasonable advertised luxuries of actual windows, functional lighting, and warm, adjustable water, as advertised. I got a third room- small, same problem with the lights and a damaged bathtub… only with windows this time! When trying to use the breakfast coupons at their small bar, I was told it only included one of two croissant options and a cup of drip coffee, Nine nights here? Not even one!!! Huge disappointment and completely different from what the website advertised. Total ripoff.

Excellent central location right by Times Square however it wasn’t noisy at night (we were on 31st floor). Lovely hotel, very clean and staff were all very friendly. Loved the cafe bar, food and drinks all very good. Only thing that would have made it even better is the facilities in the room. For a 5 star I would have expected better tea and coffee making facilities as the machine provided wasn’t great and only coffee was provided no tea