Buttonwood Cay

The property itself was beautiful. A fantastic pool and a private beach! Staff were friendly but it often felt like service was quite slow (the hotel wasn’t all that busy, but when we let the front desk know that we didn’t have towels, it was almost an hour before we got any; similarly, it took us about 20 minutes to get drinks in an almost-empty bar). One important thing to note is that everything nearby shuts down at 5pm when the cruise boats leave. Our options for dinner were: eat at the hotel restaurant; get McDonald’s across the street; or take a taxi to a restaurant elsewhere on the island. We wish we’d known this in advance and could have planned accordingly.