Independent hotels in Fire Island, New York

"Staff is helpful. Gym is a little small, but room is comfortable and it’s a convenient location. "

"N/A"

"Loved it! The workers were so kind and helpful! The facility was also immaculate and clean. "

"Great location. "

"We enjoyed our stay at Jake's 58. Room prices were very reasonable. The rooms are very comfortable and roomy enough. It was a plus to have a refrigerator in the room. Going downstairs for coffee/tea etc. was very easy and not too inconvenient. We appreciated the amount of security at the doors. Valet service makes parking less of a hassle as long as you don't mind spending $10 each time you park. We would stay again."

"We arrived early and Janet at the front desk was so accommodating she was able to get us signed in and our room was very comfortable "

"Always my choice when staying in the area. Staff very friendly. Check in is quick and easy. Not to mention the newly renovated rooms. "

"Clean rooms"

"Super clean hotel room with a private bathroom. And the bathroom was new and large!! Would definitely stay here again. Thank you to Tyler for all your assistance and making our stay comfortable!"