Independent hotels in Fire Island, New York

"The room was clean, the staff was friendly, the beds were comfortable, the food was delicious, and the casino was fun!"

"Super nice professionally "

"King deluxe suite was worth the extra money. Stayed 5 weeks and I would stay again if I come back."

"I didn’t take the time to eat but considering part of the hotel is under construction, my stay was excellent. Chelsea at the front desk was helpful and when I arrived for late check in, she recognized my name as my husband had called her earlier to let her know I was running a little behind. Everyone at desk also were very nice. "

"Great place! "

"Really enjoyed our stay"

"Great customer service, my temperature control wasn't working when I arrived late at night and they sent up an engineer that fixed it right away. The rest of my stay was nice, quiet at night good for sleeping."

"great overall "

"More menu variety"