Preferred hotels in Fire Island, New York

"Ice machine didn’t have ice was only negative "

"We arrived on Long Island very late on the 10th. We were at a hotel that was completely horrid and we had to get out of there. We left there the morning of the 12th and booked the Marriott. We left without showering and needed to get ourselves together for the day. The staff at the Marriott allowed us to get into a room around 11 and helped us tremendously. We really couldn't wait until 3pm check in. We were given waters and greeted with smiles. Our room was clean and very comfortable. Plenty of towels and everything we needed. Bed comfortable. Only request I would make is to make the quiet hours sign more visible. No one sees that on the door outside the elevator. We had lots of noise after midnight with very loud talking and kids running in the halls. "

"Very convenient for me "

"Simple, clean, convenient, friendly staff, affordable "

"This is really a 5 star hotel, I don’t give this out often but this was a 10/10 experience. Loved everything about this place. "

"Quick check in, very nice and professional front desk staff "

"Same as the picture "

"Very Happy to find a clean, comfortable room and bathroom with a comfy bed!"

"Place was beautiful and well maintained "