Fishers Island Holidays

The hotel is a little dated, but it's clean and very well located. The small kitchen allowed us to cook breakfast and save some money. The front desk staff was friendly.

You will need to insert your key into a box beside the door to turn on the lights and tv.

Upon check in no one told me that in order to turn on the AC/electricity in the room your key card must be inserted at all times. Upon learning this, we decided to leave the key in while we were out. We were gone for hours and returned to find our room was 80 degrees. Called the front desk and they sent someone up to help fix the issue, they were in and out a few times but the room never cooled. The front desk let us know if we packed up all our stuff and took it down the next morning, when a new room was available they would take our stuff up for us. The next morning we did just that, waited 30 min for an elevator that never came, seemed like only 1 out of 3 elevators was working. Had to leave our luggage in the room and take the stairs from the 7th floor down to the lobby. We spoke with a woman who claimed she was one of the managers about our issues and she explained that the elevators take long because they use one to take people up to the 5th floor for breakfast, breakfast was included in our reservations but we never attempted to go because you have to go check in on the 1st floor and they take you up to the 5th floor with a special key card, line was always long. I let the manager know I wanted a key card left in the room they switched us into so the ac could be left on and she acted like that was too big an ask. I have 3 children, I could not walk into a hot room again. The new room temperature never got below 72. Worst experience. Never staying here again.

Spacious and retro looking room creates a perfect setting at this gem of a hotel.

The hotel was very clean, quiet, and in a great location! The air conditioning was the best to come back to after being outside in the heat and humidity. The only downside, and it's not anything major, was most of the ice machines were out of order except for the one on the fourth floor. Overall, we had a great experience though and would definitely stay here again!