Best Western hotels in Island Park, New York

"Everything nice"

"The L Hotel is an excellent value for a cozy stay! The staff was incredibly friendly and welcoming, making mine and my boyfriend’s experience even more enjoyable. I especially appreciated the convenient parking available in the back. The complimentary breakfast was a nice touch, adding to the overall comfort. I will definitely continue to book this hotel for future stays!"

"Great"

"Clean room"

"Positive: Easily walkable in 5 minutes to Nevins Street subway station. Staff courteous and helpful at reception desk and housekeeping. Convenient adjacent restaurant accessible directly from lobby. Snacks and toiletries available next to reception desk. Negative: Our 6th floor room's furniture and built-ins were a bit worn out and did not match the floorplan layout shown on the door. The room had obviously been converted from a single king-size bed room to a two double-size bed room (not queens). However, the desk staff indicated all the bedrooms were being entirely renovated, currently (April 2026) doing so on the uppermost floor (13th? 14th?), then will be moving down the building one floor at a time. So it may be some time before all the room are refurbished."

"Shuttle took more than An hour to arrive!! "

"it was ok"

"Loved the room! I found myself just looking out the window and on the balcony. With the right weather, I would have never left. It is a great spot and I’d love to go back!"

"Everything is good "