Independent hotels in Madeline Island, Wisconsin

"Everything was clean and well maintained."

"I've stayed here 2 times and have only been happy with my stay. The location is fabulous with sweeping views of Lake Superior all around. I feel that it is an excellent value for what you get compared to other hotels and inns on the water. The staff has always been friendly and I find the size of the property charming. It is not a typical large casino resort but I appreciate ease of getting around, location and personable staff. I made an error when booking my room that they were extremely willing to work with me on and even booked it through a 3rd party. I will definitely stay here again...without hesitation!"

"Our room was ready and we were able to check in early. We appreciated that. "

"Great"

"This newer hotel was centrally located to a number of Northeastern Wisconsin activities. Bayfield, Hayward, Great Lakes Visitors Center and Ashland itself, are all within an hours drive or less. Ashland's Murals are well worth locating and viewing - an amazing city project. Breakfast at Cobblestone was different each day and good. Staff was helpful and friendly."

"The view was amazing and the building had great character "

"Great location, great fit for our get away."

"Our bathroom ceiling had a slow water drip above the toilet. We called maintenance and they fixed it quickly. "

"We had an amazing family vacation staying at the Sunset Bay Lodge. The beach and dock area was a highlight for our group. We spent plenty of time hanging out at the water; sunning, playing and fires. The paddle boards and Kayaks were a VERY nice inclusion. The hunt for sea glass was a constant adventure. The house was very spacious and accommodating for large groups. The extended dining table is great for everyone to eat together. There are plenty of cups, plates and silverware. The massive fridge and freezer were perfect for our large group. The house boasts plenty of room to hangout indoors on those rainy days. We were thankful for the pile of wood the owners supplied for the outdoor fire pits. That is a very nice inclusion. One item to note is that guests are responsible for removal and disposal of their own garbage via the town recycling center just down the road. The center is only open certain days, so plan accordingly. The cost is 5 per small white garbage bag and 10 per large black bag. Thankfully we brought a few large black bags as we were able to fit 4-5 white bags in each black bag:)We will definitely consider staying at the Sunset Bay Lodge in the future. "