Cheap flights from Shelter Island starting at

Cheapest flights from Shelter Island

These prices were available within the past 7 days. Prices quoted are per person, return, for the period specified. Prices and availability are subject to change. Additional terms apply.

Sat, 29 Aug - Wed, 2 Sept

HVN

New Haven

MCO

Orlando

€114 Return, found 3 days ago

€114

Return

found 3 days ago

Select Avelo Airlines flight, departing Sat, 29 Aug from New Haven to Orlando, returning Wed, 2 Sept, priced at €114 found 3 days ago

Sat, 12 Sept - Mon, 14 Sept

SWF

Newburgh

MCO

Orlando

€127 Return, found 3 days ago

€127

Return

found 3 days ago

Select Breeze Airways flight, departing Sat, 12 Sept from Newburgh to Orlando, returning Mon, 14 Sept, priced at €127 found 3 days ago

Sat, 29 Aug - Wed, 2 Sept

HVN

New Haven

FLL

Fort Lauderdale

€148 Return, found 3 days ago

€148

Return

found 3 days ago

Select Avelo Airlines flight, departing Sat, 29 Aug from New Haven to Fort Lauderdale, returning Wed, 2 Sept, priced at €148 found 3 days ago

Sun, 6 Sept - Thu, 10 Sept

EWR

New York

MCO

Orlando

€150 Return, found 2 days ago

€150

Return

found 2 days ago

Select Breeze Airways flight, departing Sun, 6 Sept from New York to Orlando, returning Thu, 10 Sept, priced at €150 found 2 days ago

Sat, 26 Sept - Sat, 3 Oct

EWR

New York

FLL

Fort Lauderdale

€162 Return, found 1 day ago

€162

Return

found 1 day ago

Select JetBlue Airways flight, departing Sat, 26 Sept from New York to Fort Lauderdale, returning Sat, 3 Oct, priced at €162 found 1 day ago

Sat, 26 Sept - Sat, 3 Oct

LGA

New York

FLL

Fort Lauderdale

€162 Return, found 1 day ago

€162

Return

found 1 day ago

Select American Airlines flight, departing Sat, 26 Sept from New York to Fort Lauderdale, returning Sat, 3 Oct, priced at €162 found 1 day ago

Sat, 26 Sept - Sat, 3 Oct

JFK

New York

FLL

Fort Lauderdale

€162 Return, found 10 hours ago

€162

Return

found 10 hours ago

Select Delta flight, departing Sat, 26 Sept from New York to Fort Lauderdale, returning Sat, 3 Oct, priced at €162 found 10 hours ago

Sat, 19 Sept - Sat, 3 Oct

JFK

New York

MIA

Miami

€164 Return, found 4 days ago

€164

Return

found 4 days ago

Select Delta flight, departing Sat, 19 Sept from New York to Miami, returning Sat, 3 Oct, priced at €164 found 4 days ago

Sat, 26 Sept - Mon, 28 Sept

LGA

New York

MCO

Orlando

€171 Return, found 1 hour ago

€171

Return

found 1 hour ago

Select Delta flight, departing Sat, 26 Sept from New York to Orlando, returning Mon, 28 Sept, priced at €171 found 1 hour ago

Sat, 26 Sept - Mon, 28 Sept

JFK

New York

MCO

Orlando

€171 Return, found 1 hour ago

€171

Return

found 1 hour ago

Select Delta flight, departing Sat, 26 Sept from New York to Orlando, returning Mon, 28 Sept, priced at €171 found 1 hour ago

Sat, 19 Sept - Sun, 20 Sept

LGA

New York

MIA

Miami

€189 Return, found 3 days ago

€189

Return

found 3 days ago

Select American Airlines flight, departing Sat, 19 Sept from New York to Miami, returning Sun, 20 Sept, priced at €189 found 3 days ago

Sat, 26 Sept - Mon, 28 Sept

EWR

New York

MIA

Miami

€189 Return, found 4 days ago

€189

Return

found 4 days ago

Select American Airlines flight, departing Sat, 26 Sept from New York to Miami, returning Mon, 28 Sept, priced at €189 found 4 days ago

Sat, 3 Oct - Wed, 7 Oct

JFK

New York

SJU

San Juan

€221 Return, found 12 hours ago

€221

Return

found 12 hours ago

Select JetBlue Airways flight, departing Sat, 3 Oct from New York to San Juan, returning Wed, 7 Oct, priced at €221 found 12 hours ago

Sat, 26 Sept - Mon, 28 Sept

HVN

New Haven

SJU

San Juan

€228 Return, found 3 days ago

€228

Return

found 3 days ago

Select Avelo Airlines flight, departing Sat, 26 Sept from New Haven to San Juan, returning Mon, 28 Sept, priced at €228 found 3 days ago

Sat, 12 Sept - Fri, 18 Sept

LGA

New York

SJU

San Juan

€229 Return, found 1 day ago

€229

Return

found 1 day ago

Select American Airlines flight, departing Sat, 12 Sept from New York to San Juan, returning Fri, 18 Sept, priced at €229 found 1 day ago

Sat, 12 Sept - Fri, 18 Sept

EWR

New York

SJU

San Juan

€229 Return, found 1 day ago

€229

Return

found 1 day ago

Select American Airlines flight, departing Sat, 12 Sept from New York to San Juan, returning Fri, 18 Sept, priced at €229 found 1 day ago

Sun, 13 Sept - Sat, 19 Sept

JFK

New York

LAS

Las Vegas

€255 Return, just found

€255

Return

just found

Select American Airlines flight, departing Sun, 13 Sept from New York to Las Vegas, returning Sat, 19 Sept, priced at €255 just found

Sat, 26 Sept - Sat, 3 Oct

LGA

New York

LAS

Las Vegas

€272 Return, found 1 hour ago

€272

Return

found 1 hour ago

Select American Airlines flight, departing Sat, 26 Sept from New York to Las Vegas, returning Sat, 3 Oct, priced at €272 found 1 hour ago

Tue, 27 Oct - Sat, 31 Oct

EWR

New York

LAS

Las Vegas

€273 Return, found 1 day ago

€273

Return

found 1 day ago

Select Delta flight, departing Tue, 27 Oct from New York to Las Vegas, returning Sat, 31 Oct, priced at €273 found 1 day ago

Mon, 7 Dec - Wed, 16 Dec

JFK

New York

MBJ

Montego Bay

€274 Return, found 2 days ago

€274

Return

found 2 days ago

Select JetBlue Airways flight, departing Mon, 7 Dec from New York to Montego Bay, returning Wed, 16 Dec, priced at €274 found 2 days ago