Carroll Hotels

"We always enjoy our stay here"

"Property was very easy to find and very cute. Perfect for a girls trip! The owner is very responsive and friendly. Sydney the kitty was a very gracious hostess as well! It's a beautiful area, only 10 minutes from Olean. Definitely want to stay here again. I cannot recommend this property enough. Thank you!"

"I checked in, but assigned room had an unpleasant smell. Consierge was understanding and gave me another room which was clean and warm. In the morning I had a nice hot shower and went for breakfast at 8am. I believe there were only a few people staying so it's difficult to estimate amount of hot meals to prepare , so consequently little remained after 8am. My breafast was adequate though. All in all I was quite satisfied with my stay."

"Room was clean. The beds were not the greatest, the memory foam topper made us roll to the middle of the bed. Breakfast was 5-9 am, 6-10 would have been more ideal. This left many guests rushing to grab something to eat before 9. The layout of the parking lot made for pretty tight parking. It was just ok and because of the beds, we’ll probably find another place next time. "

"My husband and I have never stayed in a B&B before. We had a wonderful experience with the Old Library Inn. Our room was decorated beautifully, and very clean. The bathroom was especially immaculate and the linens were soft, fresh and plentiful. Breakfast was fresh made to order and delicious. I felt very relaxed and comfortable in the living room area and kitchen. A wonderful stay and I will be back!"

"Parking ok didn’t eat breakfast "

"Overall, a great place! Good staff and breakfast was better than most places. Unfortunately, the bed was just really firm and uncomfortable. Also, the sink would take ages to drain and the body soap wasn't refilled before we checked in. Just little criticisms for an overall great experience!"

"Everything is very good - the only negative - a bit pricey"

"The property appears to have been enhanced within the last several years--carpets, cabinets, lobby, lounge/restaurant. Our particular room had very stained shears on the windows, and the tub could benefit from new caulking as well as ceiling repair. Breakfast was a bit less than the typical included choices for these types of hotels (no fresh fruit, no yogurt)."