City Island Holidays

Great location. Nice clean boutique hotel with friendly staff. Bed is comfortable. Duvet cover on comforter! Not a comforter wrapped in sheets that come off while you’re sleeping like most hotels. This is a nice touch.

You book this hotel for the location. Amenities, service are ok. People are friendly and willing to help but some thing are just the way they are. AC don’t work all the time, when it did it produced a high pitched noise, there was this flashing light right above the bed that was seemingly random in its blinking pattern sometimes really bright other times not noticeable. Our first room had a view of construction equipment, second room on floor 10 was a lot better. TV stopped working after first night, two asks to fix nothing changed. It was really nice to be able to drink from the taps in the bathroom.

Great front desk staff!! Other than the guy who barely acknowledged me and only took out one earbud to talk to me and seemed bother that I had inte was really great friendly and professional. Room was very comfy and spacious.

No a/c. Everything else was perfect, but the lack of a/c was an issue. I couldn't get that good hotel sleep because it was so hot and uncomfortable in my room. Even the lobby was hot. It just made no sense. Out of 5 stars, I'd give the place 2 out of 5 simply due to no a/c. I took cold showers multiple times. I just hated it.

Staff was extremely helpful. The Hudson view was beautiful. Relatively quiet area but easy access to everything via bus or ferry.