Mattituck Holidays

Very close to Times Square

I thought the rooms were difficult to cool. Humidity was very high.

The lobby and front desk team were the highlights of this hotel. However, the room was quite rundown. As a solo traveler, I did not feel safe at this property. Most hotels require you to use your key to access your floor, but this one did not have that security feature. Additionally, the room's lock had a chain lock, which further contributed to my discomfort regarding safety.

Pros: - Good water pressure & temp - A/C works well - Large room - Clean sheets / comfortable bed - No pests or vermin - Nice staff - Quiet elevators even for adjacent room Cons: - Room keys frequently need to be reset - Elevator out of commission, down to single elevator - Leak in bathroom faucet, mold behind other faucet/backsplash - Aging fixtures - Some disrepair - gouges in wall, carpet unraveling, broken tile, shade roller chain unanchored from drywall - strange organic debris in kitchen sink I've stayed at better in the area for the same price

Hotel was absolutely perfect.