St. Athernase Church

Advertised as a boutique 4* hotel but is not. Very good: ease of booking Good: parking, location Adequate: the cooked breakfast was hot and the eggs poached well. The 4 poster bed was a nice feature. Below par: very limited breakfast options, and the need to decide the night before is very odd and burdensome. The business is in effect a mediocre B&B within a grand old Edinburgh sandstone house - which needs a deep clean and ver considerable repair/refurbishment. Windows are single glazed, have rotten frames and are wedged permanently open so there is a lot of sound pollution from ambulances outside. Bathroom fixtures and fittings old and need upgrading. Overall a mediocre experience

My group had such a wonderful experience at this hotel. The location was incredible and we found the rooms sufficiently spacious. The best part of our stay was by far the staff - specifically, Emma at the front desk was incredibly kind and accommodating to our group when we had an unexpected emergency come up. Every other worker was also kind and friendly. Would absolutely stay here again.

My room clean and bright. My stay was for three nights but I saw someone at reception only when I checked in. The chambermaid was very pleasant. There appeared to be no information regarding the Wi-Fi password available. Public transport into the city centre was excellent.