Independent hotels in Summerland Key, Florida
Change your mindBook hotels with free cancellation
Be pickySearch almost a million properties worldwide
Check prices for these dates
Top Summerland Key Hotel Reviews
Sugarloaf Key Hotel at KOA Resort
8/10 Good
"Overall, we had a nice stay and enjoyed the property. The staff was friendly, and the amenities were great. However, the room could have been much cleaner upon arrival. We understand that the property is pet-friendly, and we love dogs, but the floors were extremely dirty, and pet hair was everywhere throughout the room. Also, since there is no housekeeping service, I ended up having to clean quite a bit myself during our stay. With better cleaning standards, this would have been an excellent experience."
Oceanside Paradise in the FL Keys Free Kayaks Bikes Community Pool & Hot Tub
10/10 Excellent
"Our stay was wonderful. The house had everything we needed; beach towels, bikes, kayaks, ice machine, umbrellas and chairs. They thought of everything. The beds were super comfy, and there were plenty of board games and cards. The pool at the complex was nice and the community was friendly. Highly recommend!"
Parmer's Resort
10/10 Excellent
"The staff here are amazing they are so nice and helpful. The breakfast in the morning was much more than we had expected and cookies and lemonade in the afternoon was a special treat again not expected but a nice touch. Our room was somewhat dated but we’re not there to spend time in the room. My only complaint would be to please update the bed it was not comfortable at all. But I would still give this place 5 stars and recommend it to anyone. Lots of great places to eat in the area and close to places of interest."
Open Water View from porch , golf cart, dock, bikes, kayaks, trailer parking
8/10 Good
"Very clean and nice home. Host was quick to respond. There was a lot of seaweed which made it difficult to take our boat in/out. We had to manually pull/push it to avoid seaweed getting into the engine. The community pool is very nice and well maintained."
Sugar Loaf Lodge
10/10 Excellent
"Great location for us. Clean room for 2. Ice machine worked well. Hotel employees friendly and helpful. Coming back later this year."
SEA SHELL COTTAGE, perfect for 2. Summer fun boating, fishing 🎣 and 🦞 Lobster
10/10 Excellent
"Had a great 5 night stay wish it was longer. Very clean and well appointed. Tonios was amazing. Great coffee and sandwiches at 5 brothers just down the street Pool was perfect for my morning laps. Definitely would rent again"
Sugarloaf Key RV Resort & Cottages
10/10 Excellent
"First time staying here it won’t be our last!"
Waterfront 2BR Home w/ Dock + Golf Cart, Open Water Views in Venture Out
8/10 Good
"The property is on a beautiful view of water, and the communication by the host was excellent. Distance from Key West was good and allowed you to be a little outside of the fray. Three pieces of constructive feedback. We stay a lot in Vrbo‘s and the general expectation is that there is sufficient things like toilet paper, paper towel, dishwasher detergent and coffee pods for a Keurig machine that is there. These were not included, other than a starter roll of TP and paper towel. While it apparently says that in the listing, we didn’t catch it because we have grown accustomed to just having it stocked. Given the price, that would be a simple audition and would make a big difference. Labeling the three remotes in the living room, would’ve been helpful. We never could figure out the TV. And last, the golf cart is a big bonus, especially when you have aging people with you. However, the golf cart is in bad shape, it’s old and the brake needs to be fixed. Other than that, it was worth the stay."
Private Oceanfront Cottage with dockage, pool just minutes to Key West!
10/10 Excellent
"This is our second stay at cottage 1 and it’s our little slice of heaven. Nothing fancy but love the property. You will see Iguana's and different wild life. On our last day we had a Key Deer hanging out in the front yard."