Cheap flights from Shelter Island starting at

Cheapest flights from Shelter Island

These prices were available within the past 7 days. Prices quoted are per person, return, for the period specified. Prices and availability are subject to change. Additional terms apply.

Sun, 22 Feb - Thu, 5 Mar

LGA

New York

MCO

Orlando

€83 Return, found 4 days ago

€83

Return

found 4 days ago

Select American Airlines flight, departing Sun, 22 Feb from New York to Orlando, returning Thu, 5 Mar, priced at €83 found 4 days ago

Sun, 25 Jan - Thu, 29 Jan

EWR

New York

MCO

Orlando

€96 Return, found 4 days ago

€96

Return

found 4 days ago

Select Breeze Airways flight, departing Sun, 25 Jan from New York to Orlando, returning Thu, 29 Jan, priced at €96 found 4 days ago

Sat, 7 Feb - Tue, 10 Feb

LGA

New York

FLL

Fort Lauderdale

€109 Return, found 6 days ago

€109

Return

found 6 days ago

Select Delta flight, departing Sat, 7 Feb from New York to Fort Lauderdale, returning Tue, 10 Feb, priced at €109 found 6 days ago

Sun, 25 Jan - Thu, 29 Jan

SWF

Newburgh

MCO

Orlando

€113 Return, found 4 days ago

€113

Return

found 4 days ago

Select Breeze Airways flight, departing Sun, 25 Jan from Newburgh to Orlando, returning Thu, 29 Jan, priced at €113 found 4 days ago

Wed, 18 Feb - Thu, 19 Feb

JFK

New York

MCO

Orlando

€118 Return, found 2 days ago

€118

Return

found 2 days ago

Select JetBlue Airways flight, departing Wed, 18 Feb from New York to Orlando, returning Thu, 19 Feb, priced at €118 found 2 days ago

Sat, 31 Jan - Sat, 31 Jan

JFK

New York

FLL

Fort Lauderdale

€122 Return, found 3 hours ago

€122

Return

found 3 hours ago

Select JetBlue Airways flight, departing Sat, 31 Jan from New York to Fort Lauderdale, returning Sat, 31 Jan, priced at €122 found 3 hours ago

Sat, 21 Feb - Wed, 25 Feb

EWR

New York

MIA

Miami

€123 Return, found 5 days ago

€123

Return

found 5 days ago

Select American Airlines flight, departing Sat, 21 Feb from New York to Miami, returning Wed, 25 Feb, priced at €123 found 5 days ago

Sat, 21 Feb - Wed, 25 Feb

JFK

New York

MIA

Miami

€123 Return, found 5 days ago

€123

Return

found 5 days ago

Select American Airlines flight, departing Sat, 21 Feb from New York to Miami, returning Wed, 25 Feb, priced at €123 found 5 days ago

Sun, 8 Feb - Thu, 12 Feb

LGA

New York

MIA

Miami

€123 Return, found 4 days ago

€123

Return

found 4 days ago

Select Delta flight, departing Sun, 8 Feb from New York to Miami, returning Thu, 12 Feb, priced at €123 found 4 days ago

Thu, 12 Mar - Tue, 17 Mar

EWR

New York

FLL

Fort Lauderdale

€135 Return, found 2 days ago

€135

Return

found 2 days ago

Select Delta flight, departing Thu, 12 Mar from New York to Fort Lauderdale, returning Tue, 17 Mar, priced at €135 found 2 days ago

Mon, 26 Jan - Tue, 3 Feb

JFK

New York

SJU

San Juan

€153 Return, found 6 days ago

€153

Return

found 6 days ago

Select JetBlue Airways flight, departing Mon, 26 Jan from New York to San Juan, returning Tue, 3 Feb, priced at €153 found 6 days ago

Mon, 9 Feb - Fri, 13 Feb

EWR

New York

SJU

San Juan

€156 Return, found 5 days ago

€156

Return

found 5 days ago

Select American Airlines flight, departing Mon, 9 Feb from New York to San Juan, returning Fri, 13 Feb, priced at €156 found 5 days ago

Mon, 9 Feb - Fri, 13 Feb

LGA

New York

SJU

San Juan

€161 Return, found 5 days ago

€161

Return

found 5 days ago

Select American Airlines flight, departing Mon, 9 Feb from New York to San Juan, returning Fri, 13 Feb, priced at €161 found 5 days ago

Sun, 8 Feb - Tue, 10 Feb

EWR

New York

LAS

Las Vegas

€161 Return, found 5 days ago

€161

Return

found 5 days ago

Select JetBlue Airways flight, departing Sun, 8 Feb from New York to Las Vegas, returning Tue, 10 Feb, priced at €161 found 5 days ago

Thu, 22 Jan - Wed, 28 Jan

EWR

New York

LAX

Los Angeles

€162 Return, found 6 days ago

€162

Return

found 6 days ago

Select American Airlines flight, departing Thu, 22 Jan from New York to Los Angeles, returning Wed, 28 Jan, priced at €162 found 6 days ago

Thu, 29 Jan - Wed, 4 Feb

JFK

New York

LAX

Los Angeles

€169 Return, found 5 days ago

€169

Return

found 5 days ago

Select American Airlines flight, departing Thu, 29 Jan from New York to Los Angeles, returning Wed, 4 Feb, priced at €169 found 5 days ago

Mon, 26 Jan - Tue, 3 Feb

LGA

New York

LAX

Los Angeles

€182 Return, found 6 days ago

€182

Return

found 6 days ago

Select American Airlines flight, departing Mon, 26 Jan from New York to Los Angeles, returning Tue, 3 Feb, priced at €182 found 6 days ago

Sat, 7 Mar - Tue, 10 Mar

JFK

New York

LAS

Las Vegas

€187 Return, found 2 days ago

€187

Return

found 2 days ago

Select JetBlue Airways flight, departing Sat, 7 Mar from New York to Las Vegas, returning Tue, 10 Mar, priced at €187 found 2 days ago

Thu, 19 Feb - Wed, 25 Feb

LGA

New York

LAS

Las Vegas

€195 Return, found 4 days ago

€195

Return

found 4 days ago

Select American Airlines flight, departing Thu, 19 Feb from New York to Las Vegas, returning Wed, 25 Feb, priced at €195 found 4 days ago

Sat, 7 Mar - Mon, 16 Mar

EWR

New York

SDQ

Santo Domingo

€241 Return, found 1 day ago

€241

Return

found 1 day ago

Select Arajet flight, departing Sat, 7 Mar from New York to Santo Domingo, returning Mon, 16 Mar, priced at €241 found 1 day ago