Plum Island Luxury Holidays

Amazong staff, amazing rooms, amazing location would definitely stay there again in New York!!

Great location, clean, courteous staff, breakfast buffet had lots of options. Would definately stay again.

Great experience Personal was amazing and very helpful I will recommend 100%

All staff we came into contact with from front desk to housekeeping to breakfast/happy hour to doormen were super attentive, very friendly and seemed to sincerely see us. The happy hour/dinner and breakfast provided surprisingly good food, lots of variety and very generous pours! Sonia was a standout and we looked forward to seeing her each evening. Beds and bedding very comfortable. Room nicely appointed and clean.

The only reason I didn’t give 5 stars is because of how small the rooms are! I had a queen standard and only travel with a carry on backpack. I had absolutely no where to put anything! If two people shared this room and you both had suitcases, I literally have no idea where you would put all your stuff. There is only enough room to barely walk around the bed, but you have to close the bathroom door and then shimmy between the “closet” and the bed. Other than that, absolutely great location, easy to get to and from JFK, and the staff were super friendly.

All staff we came into contact with from front desk to housekeeping to breakfast/happy hour to doormen were super attentive, very friendly and seemed to sincerely see us. The happy hour/dinner and breakfast provided surprisingly good food, lots of variety and very generous pours! Sonia was a standout and we looked forward to seeing her each evening. Beds and bedding very comfortable. Room nicely appointed and clean.

Absolute perfection.

I was pretty surprised how quickly this place has gone downhill in just the last 12-18 months given it’s still a relatively new property.

Amazong staff, amazing rooms, amazing location would definitely stay there again in New York!!

Great location, clean, courteous staff, breakfast buffet had lots of options. Would definately stay again.

All staff we came into contact with from front desk to housekeeping to breakfast/happy hour to doormen were super attentive, very friendly and seemed to sincerely see us. The happy hour/dinner and breakfast provided surprisingly good food, lots of variety and very generous pours! Sonia was a standout and we looked forward to seeing her each evening. Beds and bedding very comfortable. Room nicely appointed and clean.