Plum Island Hotels

"Breakfast was good but the same every day. "

"Super cute boutique hotel. Excellent staff, quiet and clean neighborhood, close to good shopping and restaurants."

"Great experience "

"Clean room, nice tv to watch football! "

"Great comfy rooms. Love the decor"

"This hotel was very accommodating, clean, and located in a safe area. I loved the architecture around it. If I needed to go to Upper Manhattan, I would just hop on the subway and get there easily. The Financial District is tucked away in Lower Manhattan, but it’s close to the Brooklyn Bridge—perfect for a walk—and also close to the Staten Island Ferry, which is free. Overall, if most of your plans are in Upper Manhattan, staying in FiDi may not be ideal, but it’s a great option for the price. Also they have complimentary breakfast and wine and cheese hour."

"Great stay!"

"Virgin is the Best Service allways. But if you are lucky and have Daniel in the Check in you will find a friend. One of the best experiences in hotels, I arrived so tired and not in the best humor and Daniel make me laugh and have all perfect. "

"This place is a fantastic find! CLEAN, safe, affordable, amazing location, and the loveliest staff! I would definitely stay again. HOWEVER, this is not a place for light sleepers. Don't get me wrong, it was quiet - everyone is so respectful of each other - but you will hear every door being opened and closed at all hours, every jacket or boot zipper being pulled up or down, every time someone clears their throat. All normal human sounds that you would not notice if they were coming from another room but as you sleep in a 4 walled cabin without ceilings, you are essentially all in the SAME room. Also, if you are a light sleeper, be sure to ask for a room at the "back" away from the noisy main road and high traffic starwell."