Plum Island Hotels

"Great hidden gem! "

"Everything was great !!"

"Bar offered a good selection only issue was sometimes unable to get a table for houseguests"

"Incredibly friendly, courteous, and helpful staff. My room was quiet, impeccably clean, and the bed was comfy. Will stay here again when visiting family. "

"Clean room"

"The breakfast menu was good, the only suggestion will be to have either chicken, turkey or vegan options at all times instead of just pork. Other than that, the staff (especially Latoya the manager) always go above and beyond with a bright smile. The cleanliness is impeccable!!! "

"Small rooms, and we had an issue with our hot water which was never really resolved. Staff was nice though! The restaurants and bars were fine. "

"It was great! Clean environment and great staff!"

"Hotel was just ok. Small but expected in NYC. However, lobby was hot. Front desk not always manned and no way to get in touch. No front desk number easily available to call. No one ever answered the "chat" that is available online. My room was stocked with off-brand cofee pods and ALL decaf. Very disappointed in the morning. No one from the front desk ever responded to me to refill with med or dark roast caffeinated coffee--and I was there for 2 nights. No water in rooms. Paper cups. Old, sticky hairdryer that barely worked. Old fridge that was difficult to access and didn't get very cold. Old AC unit. Shower escheteons coming out of wall. "