Our top choices for Plum Island hotels

PUBLIC, an Ian Schrager hotel

Manhattan

Carlos

includes taxes & fees

25 May - 26 May

Days Inn by Wyndham New York Chinatown

Manhattan

Carlos

includes taxes & fees

25 May - 26 May

Hotel Henri NY

Manhattan

SHARI

includes taxes & fees

21 May - 22 May

DoubleTree by Hilton New York Downtown

Manhattan

Mauricio

includes taxes & fees

25 May - 26 May

1 bedroom, Egyptian cotton sheets, premium bedding, down duvets

Artezen Hotel

Manhattan

Monica

includes taxes & fees

25 May - 26 May

Premium bedding, in-room safe, iron/ironing board, free WiFi

AMTD Idea Tribeca Hotel

Manhattan

Meredith

includes taxes & fees

25 May - 26 May

Hilton Garden Inn NYC Financial Center/Manhattan Downtown

Manhattan

Nicholas

includes taxes & fees

25 May - 26 May

Nester Finn Financial District

Manhattan

John

includes taxes & fees

31 May - 1 Jun

Deluxe Suite, 1 King Bed, Terrace, City View | Terrace/patio

Soho 54

Manhattan

Sarah

includes taxes & fees

25 May - 26 May

Best Western Plus Soho Hotel

Manhattan

Alesha

includes taxes & fees

25 May - 26 May

The Cloud One New York-Downtown, by the Motel One Group

Manhattan

Nancy

includes taxes & fees

25 May - 26 May

Hotel Richland LES

Manhattan

Caitlyn

includes taxes & fees

25 May - 26 May

In-room safe, desk, blackout curtains, iron/ironing board

The Allen Hotel

Manhattan

Mark

includes taxes & fees

25 May - 26 May

Suite, Refrigerator & Microwave (One Room)

World Center Hotel

Manhattan

John

includes taxes & fees

25 May - 26 May

Hotel Indigo NYC Financial District by IHG

Manhattan

Aslan

includes taxes & fees

25 May - 26 May

Residence Inn Marriott New York Downtown Manhattan/WTC Area

Manhattan

SOTTHEARY

includes taxes & fees

25 May - 26 May

Tribeca Hotel FiDi

Manhattan

Geovana

includes taxes & fees

25 May - 26 May

Motto by Hilton New York City Chelsea

Manhattan

Cristian

includes taxes & fees

25 May - 26 May

The Gatsby Hotel

Manhattan

Steven

includes taxes & fees

31 May - 1 Jun

AC Hotel by Marriott New York Downtown

Manhattan

Merrick

includes taxes & fees

25 May - 26 May

View all properties

Save an average of 15% on thousands of hotels when you're signed in

Sign in

Sign up, it's free

Stay near popular Plum Island attractions

Winter scene of the Sandy Hook Lighthouse, Gateway National Recreation Area, Highlands, Monmouth County, New Jersey.

Sandy Hook Gateway National Recreation Area

4.2/5 (30 reviews)

Explore the great outdoors at Sandy Hook Gateway National Recreation Area, a lovely green space in Highlands. While you're in the area, stroll along the beautiful beaches.

See properties

Learn more about Plum Island

Venture to sights like Sandy Hook Lighthouse and Sandy Hook Gateway National Recreation Area as you discover Plum Island.

See all hotels in Plum Island

Top Plum Island Hotel Reviews

DoubleTree by Hilton New York Downtown

2/10 Terrible

"The staff was very rude. I had to wait at the desk several times while they come out of their little room eating. They did not have any business space for me to print . The window shade fell off the window while we came and checked in very late and we had to change rooms. I just really don’t care for rudeness by the staff."

The Shelburne Sonesta New York

8/10 Good

"The property is well-maintained and clean . The stuff is friendly. It is close to grand central and restaurants. So it is relatively convenient to get to places and enjoy foods. It’s somewhat noisy at night. There are two elevators in the building. Sometimes one has to wait for a while to use the elevators. In general I am happy with my stay :)"

DoubleTree by Hilton Hotel Newark Airport

8/10 Good

"The stay was really good the hotel was nice and staff were great- restaurants I would say tho the waitress need to get it together- waiting to long and she forgot most of my order - other then that the rooms were clean- parking was an issue as well- and they shouldn’t make guess pay for parking if they are stayin- I stayed at a few and they never made the guess pay- "

The Westin New York Grand Central

6/10 Okay

"Staff wasn’t too helpful or very nice. Good location. Clean and comfortable room. They charged us a destination fee. We were supposed to get 17.50 in credit per day for food in their restaurant . Breakfast was 45.00 each. So, we chose a couple coffees and went on our way. They didn’t charge the room for the coffee, so we couldn’t use the credit, so ended up paying 17.50 for two coffees. Quite the racket. Don’t think we will stay there again."

Freehand New York

2/10 Terrible

"The hallway carpets are dirty. So are the room carpets. There was a janky window a/c installed with some flimsy plastic sheeting around it; even in the 16th floor it was like sleeping with the window wide open and incredibly loud. No kettle or coffee maker. The bathroom was minute. The window blinds had been hung by a novice and were scratched and missing pulls. The room doors are thin - you can hear people’s conversations as you walk through the halls. I checked out the next morning and stayed elsewhere."