Best Western hotels in Plum Island, New Jersey

"Ideal location, clean and spacious room, great amenities (yoga mat, iron, Nespresso machine, etc), and hard-working house keeping staff!"

"AC was good. Slept well using sound-soother device and eye mask which were provided. Nice Italian restaurant, Gemma, across the street and several good coffee shops a short distance."

"Friendly helpful staff especially at reception. Room was clean with an excellent view. "

"Marsha made out stay so great! Terrific customer service! "

"First of all the Staff was absolutly amazing. Great hotel. Cool location close to Madison Square Garden and walkable to Time Square."

"Everything was good "

"Very clean and great location. Friendly service. Room was very small but that was to be expected. I don’t think I would have enjoyed it if I was sharing the room with others since for example the bathroom is pretty close to the bed, but I think it is great for solo traveling. Appreciated the rain shower head. The hotel has a fun, hip vibe to it. I LOVED the rooftop."

"Great area right near Penn Station and Madison Square Garden. 4 minute walk to my concert and it was so easy. Rooms were clean and the view of the Empire State is superb. Before you leave don’t forget to check out the rooftop bar. It’s free to enter and you can get an amazing selfie with the Empire State in the background up there."

"Great staff "