Fire Island Hotel Guide - Hotels with Restaurant in Fire Island, New York

"Beautiful"

"The staff was nice/"

"Breakfast wasn’t ready at 6-630 my first nights stay of 2"

"My room # 219 had torn rugs, damaged furniture and the entryway door was stuck closed while using the keycard forcing me to kick the door open. The hallway rugs were filthy they needed to be shampooed cleaned. The motel is currently undergoing renovations the lobby had stacks of new mattresses and bed frames. The continental breakfast was adequate coffee, bagels, cream cheese, fruits bananas, apples and oranges, one type of yogurt."

"Everything was great. The bed is firm. Breakfast was good."

"Desk fell on me, wall socket in bathroom is falling out of wall, safe doesn’t work. Wire on floor causing a tripping hazard and ceiling panel open. Ladies were polite male worker looked unhappy. Said hello first day to me. After that looked very upset or unhappy. Not saying he was intentionally rude, just curt."

"We were surprised this is considered a 4 star hotel. It is in need of a renovation. The property appeared old and run down, the main elevators weren't working or were very slow. You could not drink the water unless you are an elite member. The duvet was in between 2 thin sheets and not between an actual duvet cover. The room was clean however, which is the most important thing to me. The staff was also kind. It is also very busy with events (weddings, dance competition, etc.)"

"Property deserves zero stars. Had an awful experience. Booked through Expedia but when arrived at the hotel somebody named John could not find my booking. After several minutes of trying , he phones his boss who was able to find my booking. Once I was given the room, it was several buildings down despite the entire hotel being empty. The toilet flush was not working. The wash basin was stained. The room was probably last updated in 1950s. There was no chain lock on the door. The outside had lots of unsavory characters hanging out. I wanted to leave but I was so tired, I just crashed on the bed."

"Clean room enough parking "