Independent hotels in Straits of Mackinac, Michigan

"The staff was absolutely wonderful and extremely hard working. Loved the smores and nightly fire. Breakfast was filling and well maintained. Beds were cozy, would stay there again!"

"Better prices than the other hotels, even smaller places on the island. More entertainment options, better food at restaurants.... Just come here!"

"Employees at front desk at check in were both awesome! Beautiful room, beautiful lake view, awesome breakfast. Great location! Thank you"

"Super clean. Great winery. Near Petoskey. Be aware bathroom is shared but still a 5!"

"It was very clean and comfortable. Loved that the pool and hot tub were open 24/7. Loved the bonfire on the beach at night . Restaurant seemed to be having an issue with service so we went somewhere else to eat. The complimentary breakfast was awesome Would definitely stay again"

"The large suite was great for my family and the beach was perfect!! "

"Able to walk to everything downtown"

"The Cedar Hill Lodge is well situated for all activities in the St. Ignace area. Their staff are extremely friendly and professional and are eager to help with any question or issue. They also sell tickets and offer a free shuttle service to one of the ferries that go to Mackinac Island. I would stay here again. "

"Great place to stay on the island!"