Search Sugarloaf Key Condo Rentals

"Best place to stay in Key West! "

"Exceeded my expectations.!"

"Very nice one bedroom suite by the pool. If you have more than two I would get the two bedroom or you have to share the master bath. It was a little noisy at the pool at night but didn't really bother us much but some may not. We would stay again!"

"Very neat and clean property. Staff helpful and pleasant. Absolutely loved the location. Will be returning in December. "

"The hotel was lively. Staff is very friendly and accommodating. The beach was beautiful! Had a wonderful time and would stay there again! "

"NYAH was a nice place to stay and would consider staying there again in the future due to the price. It’s definitely not a luxury hotel. There were three of us traveling and I wanted a place that had at least three beds because we didn’t want to share a bed. This place has bunk beds that were comfortable. The room was tiny so it was not a place to hang out and watch TV or anything. The pool area was quiet. Our neighbors were a bit noisy when they came in late at night. We rented bikes for the time we were there , which is the best way to get around in Key West. "

"We stayed here for a week for our honeymoon and really enjoyed it. We had a beautiful beach view in the back of the hotel room with chairs and hammocks to chill on. We loved interacting with the tortoises and parrots. The hotel is close (5-10' walk) to several groceries stores (Publix and Winn-Dixie) as well as restaurants (local and chain). Downsides are: non-swimmable beach, limited choice breakfast, and 2-mile distance from downtown where all the attractions are. If you enjoy a more peaceful and relaxing place, you gonna like it here."

"We loved our 4 nights here, quiet and relaxed with no over crowding. Beautiful place, would defo stay again."

"The property was very beautiful! The pool area was great!! The breakfast was good, nothing out of the ordinary. The best thing was the AC worked very well!"