Preferred hotels in City Island, New York

"The staff was so great. Cocktail Libby bar was A+, ambiance was super chic and the room was spotless clean."

"The staff was fantastic! The room was so clean and pretty! I felt safe. The view was incredible! It made me want to live there :) I definitely cannot wait to book there again!"

"Staff was excellent, courteous and attentive. The room was small, but clean and always smelled great from the restaurant’s aromas. Plus, I only needed it to rest and shower, so it did the job perfectly! Another positive was that it was centrally located to many attractions, like the Raging Bull, Wall Street, Joe’s Pizza, and more! "

"Breakfast was delicious! Beds were very comfortable. "

"Friendly and accommodating staff, clean rooms, and convenient location."

"Comfortable clean rooms. Great location. Conveniently located restaurant with decent food. Can be a bit noisy given proximity to Times Square. Front desk gave us a bottle of wine (for a birthday) upon check in which was a nice touch. Great location and amenities and you pay for it. Would return 100%"

"Very clean and close to everything "

"I had a wonderful stay at the Edison Hotel. The staff were truly excellent—warm, attentive, and always willing to assist with anything I needed. The rooms are a bit on the smaller side, but they’re functional, comfortable, and thoughtfully designed for a great stay in the city. What really stood out was the overall vibe of the hotel. From the stylish atmosphere to the energy of the lobby, everything felt inviting and full of character. And the jazz vibes? Absolutely amazing. The live music added such a unique and enjoyable touch to the experience. Overall, a great stay with fantastic service, cozy rooms, and unforgettable jazz ambiance. I’d definitely stay here again."

"Excellent"