4 Star Hotels in City Island, New York

"A very welcoming hotel, thank you."

"Fantastic location so close to MSG."

"Excellent location, great service, modern and spacious rooms. "

"For the price it was fine. If I had to say anything negative it would be the rooms are small and it take time to get the elevator to tour floor"

"AC was broken but the staff was quick to fix it"

"No"

"Great location, great staff, clean room, huge bed. Now for the bad. If you dont like city noise, select your room carefully. Windows definitely are not soundproof or even slightly noise reducing, street noise (sirens, horns, etc.) was prevalent all night, but hey, it is the city! Other issue is lack of elevators. Be prepared to wait! Overall though, excellent experience and great location just south of central park next to Columbus Circle and Carnegie Hall."

"TV not plugged in, remote needed new batteries"

"Room was clean and comfortable but no coffee was provided. Hotel includes a “destination fee” but you get $15 to spend in the very overpriced market. Stay was very quiet during the week but was a little bit rowdier on weekend - would recommend asking for a room away from elevators. Area in front of hotel is a little sketch/gross due to the vacant storefront next door attracting homeless and had an overall urine smell. Location was otherwise great."