Firmdale hotels in Randall's Island, New York

"The staff was courteous and the room was clean. The location was great. We had two rooms. The room with two beds was a decent size but the king room was tiny. You barely had room to walk around the bed. "

"Absolutely Magical Stay in New York ✨ This hotel was truly magical and an experience I will never forget. We stayed in a glass room with floor-to-ceiling windows, and at night the city lights surrounding us were breathtaking. During the day, the views were just as beautiful—and waking up to snow falling over the city felt like something out of a movie. Even though the room was small, it was absolutely worth it. Being able to see the city while relaxing and even as you drift off to sleep is something you don’t experience everywhere. It made our New York trip feel extra special and romantic. The staff was friendly, welcoming, and very festive during the holidays, which added to the overall charm and atmosphere of the stay. This hotel isn’t just a place to sleep—it’s an experience. If you want to truly feel New York, especially during the winter, this is the place to stay. Loved every moment!"

"Very kind and friendly staff. Amazingly clean room and we had a balcony!! In New York?? Never had the privilege of having that! What a treat!"

"We were here for a show and dinner and it was all very nice and convenient."

"Quick and early check in. "

"Best experience "

"Staff very friendly, food/drinks were excellent and room very clean"

"Everything stood out,first of all the iconic hotel with a magazine named after it, use to read it and still do to stay in the know. The room i chose was small, but cozy and a nice viee of some of the city and skyscrapers. Nice front desk staff, jjust have them to cover their motuhs when yawning in public in front of hundreds of people. Otherwise, super clean, super quiet and close to everything. It may ne my go to on my visits back home. Grazie."

"Clean rooms, easy check in & check out. Quiet and close to a subway!"