Benchmark hotels in Upper Matecumbe Key, Islamorada

"Great quiet spot!"

"Amazing experience. Staff is amazing so are the grounds. "

"Wonderful staff, great pool, the grounds always neat and clean. The room was to die for. Beautiful views"

"I like it a lot "

"Great location, friendly and helpful staff"

"The place has been updated. Access to the beach is awesome. Tons of things to do - such as paddleboard and kayak. Sunsets are amazing. Chill! Pool is small and no view but not what we came for. "

"Excellent ! Great rooms ,very clean and spacious. Amazing amenities, the private beach with all the water attractions, adult pool was nice and quiet, customer service excellent in all areas. Will definitely coming back hopefully soon. Thanks "

"Great stay at the Sunset Inn! We are repeat visitors and highly recommend it. Great location and easy to walk to many restaurants. The rooms are very clean and it’s in a safe location."

"First time to Lime Tree and we were pleasantly surprised. Our suite was across the street from the main hotel and office. This may not be to the liking of some people but to us it was private and quiet. Our suite was very clean, had a great shower and the kitchen was well stocked. The staff was friendly and helpful. I’m hoping to return! "