Cast Iron Historic District Hotel Guide - Golf Hotels in Cast Iron Historic District, New York

"I highly recommend people to stay at the St. James Hotel! If you’re looking for a basic amenity hotel room to crash at night and explore the city all day, THIS PLACE IS FOR YOU!! I traveled to nyc to be out and about all day and come back to the hotel late to sleep. I don’t want to stay at a chain hotel and pay hundreds of dollars for 20 million amenities that I’m not going to use. The staff at the hotel are incredibly nice and helpful from the minute you check in, during your stay, to when you check out. The building itself is old but I love the charm of it and the upkeep of the building is very well done! I didn’t ever feel like there were any gross, run down parts anywhere. The only 2 small downsides with my stay were that the wifi wasn’t good (but it could also be the tall buildings around and/or the age of the hotel) and the high pitch noise from the showers (the walls are thick and you can’t hear your neighbors but if anyone showers, you definitely hear it). But besides those two things, I will DEFINITELY be staying at the hotel if I’m ever back in the city and will be recommending it to anyone that I know who’s going to the city. It’s in such a good location with lots to see and do!"

"Great customer service, awesome location and comfortable rooms!"

"Convenient to EWR airport. Shuttle bus on time. Cordial restaurant staff. Generous plate portions. Little noisy if room is facing the pool. Overall: satisfied."

"great location, hotel is in great condition and very clean. Staff were outstanding. thanks"

"I had an issue with the ac making a loud buzzing sound like a shot clock buzzer every 1-2 minutes through my first night. It took 30 minutes for a maintenance worker to enter my hotel room. Look at the unit from 15 feet away and he told me someone will come fix it. Two hours later and two trips to the front desk later, an “on call engineer” came and told me that the fan was on high and they switched it to low and she left. The buzz persisted. I asked for a different room and was told no because they were totally booked. The front desk staff member told me he would credit $90 back to my hold card that 3 days later has not been reflected. We ended up turning off the unit and were uncomfortable in our 75 degree room. Our blinds were broken. Our shower lever that switches to shower from bath did not work and we waited an hour for an engineer to fix that. He was very friendly and genuinely sorry for our inconvenience. The cleaning staff were helpful and kind. The location is nice but not worth sacrificing bare minimum offerings to be comfortable for a stay."

"Great location. Nice property for price."

"We booked an upgraded room unfortunately when we arrive, the room was not ready and it was broken. There was a lot of confusion among the staff of what was going on. We ended up waiting for many hours in a small cramped lobby. My wife is incredibly tired. We felt frustrated and angry, and when we had to be put in a room, we were putting in a room with incredibly noisy air conditioner. I was like sitting next to a diesel truck then room also was lower grade, but we stayed in there till our other room is ready. We moved into our right room ready by the television was broken, and I had a flickering light stove would give an epileptic person some sort of seizure the entire experience was lackluster and for the money that we paid it was completely underwhelming would avoid it all costs. Plus location and cleanliness negative everything else."

"Just okay."

"Great front desk! Well kept rooms and cleaning services. Perfect location! Would definitely stay here again when we visit in the future!! Thank you!"