Holiday Homes in Plum Island

"Perfect for my stay and price was attractive as well. Will look for this rental property again when coming back to this area. Home was clean, stocked more than a hotel, and provided several creatures comforts you find in a hotel. Would recommend to others."

"Great location."

"What an adorable cottage! Cute, cozy and super clean. Kelly was by far the best host we've had! She was very easy to communicate with, quick to respond and very helpful with local tips about beaches and restaurants."

"Ben was an excellent host—communication was prompt, clear, and consistent throughout our stay. The home was lovely, spotless, and well-equipped with everything needed for a comfortable visit. We especially appreciated the convenient parking garage, as well as the reliable Wi-Fi and great TV setup.The location is beautiful, with the beach nearby and a fantastic selection of shops and restaurants within easy reach."

"The house was beautiful and looks new still. In a quiet neighborhood and the host was very responsive to suggestions and to check on our needs. Close to Keansburg Beach and the amusement park. Would definitely stay here again!"

"Everything was clean, easily accessible—extra little needed trinkets for small children and a very responsive owner. Will use again!"

"The place was magnificent. Well located, clean, well appointed. Just one word of caution for older people or people with heavy bags: navigating the stairs was challenging."

"Beautiful home - we enjoyed staying here. The whole process was easy and our stay relaxing and comfortable. "

"Great location, great host communication!"

"Great week and it all started with the right house Thank you Dana"

"The house itself was amazing, very clean, modern, and the layout was great.When we checked in, we noticed that the showerhead attachment in the master bathroom was broken. So there wasn’t a working showerhead in the master shower unless you held the attachment over your head. I notified the property manager right away and sent pictures. They said that a handyman would be over at 6:30 pm. I told the property manager that we would not be home at that time but that the handyman could let himself in...

"Best place to stay on the way to the cruise port"

"Was the best place ever! I did not want to leave it was just so beautiful"

"very close to JFK and convenient location to catch early morning flights"

"Perfect getaway at a clean, friendly, fabulously located property!"

"The Maple House was perfect for our group of four adults and two little kids. It is in a great location and has everything one might need. The owner Sean is super responsive to all communication. I highly recommend this property!"

"Great location!"

"Host was very welcoming and accommodating on a busy weekend with tricky weather. The house is very comfortable and homey and was a perfect landing spot."